Germany moves to freeze Bitcoin for up to 180 days, even without access to private keys
Quick Take
- Germany's Bundestag approved a bill allowing customs to freeze suspicious Bitcoin holdings, including assets stored in self-custody wallets.
- Authorities could restrict crypto transfers for up to 180 days without controlling private keys, challenging the legal freedom of self-custody holders.
- Identifying wallet owners and enforcing transfer bans remain major hurdles, while the legislation awaits final approval.
Germany's parliament has approved legislation allowing customs authorities to freeze suspicious crypto holdings, including assets stored in self-custody wallets.
The Bundestag passed the bill on Nov. 12, advancing a broader government effort to combat money laundering and financial crime by expanding authorities' powers to investigate assets of questionable origin.
Under the proposed legislation, German customs could temporarily freeze significant assets, including cryptocurrencies, when factual evidence raises doubts about their lawful origin.
The approved committee text identifies assets worth more than €100,000 as a general benchmark for significant holdings. Authorities could also combine closely connected assets when determining whether they qualify.
Customs would initially have 30 days to investigate suspicious holdings, with a finance court authorized to extend the restriction by another 150 days if investigators demonstrate credible doubts about their origin and grounds for further investigation.
The legislation, however, has not completed its final approval process. As of Nov. 18, final consideration by the Bundesrat, Germany's chamber representing the states, and publication in the Federal Law Gazette remained outstanding.
Germany's Bitcoin freeze powers face a self-custody challenge
The proposed rules could have different consequences depending on whether investors hold their Bitcoin through centralized exchanges or control their wallets directly.
For assets held on an exchange, German authorities could issue an enforceable attachment order requiring the custodian to restrict withdrawals from an affected account.
The mechanism draws on Germany's existing tax enforcement provisions, which allow authorities to prevent third parties from releasing assets subject to a legally enforceable attachment.
However, enforcing similar restrictions against self-custody wallets presents a more complicated challenge.
Unlike centralized exchanges, self-custody wallets allow users to control the private keys needed to authorize Bitcoin transactions without relying on a financial intermediary.
Germany's proposed framework addresses such holdings by treating cryptocurrencies as attachable property rights.
Under Section 321 of the German Fiscal Code, authorities can attach certain property rights without involving a third party by serving the holder with a legal prohibition on disposing of them.
Applied to eligible self-custodied Bitcoin, this could prohibit an owner from transferring the affected assets without automatically removing their ability to authorize blockchain transactions.
Consequently, an individual could remain technically capable of moving Bitcoin despite being legally prohibited from doing so.
How custody changes a proposed Bitcoin freeze
Two ways a customs attachment could reach bitcoin, depending on who controls the transfers.
An order can restrict disposal even when the holder still controls the keys.
Illustrative cases under the Bundestag-approved bill. The diagram covers the effect of serving the attachment order.
Sources
Supporting facts
- Section 56a would implement a hold on claims and other property rights through attachment using the corresponding Fiscal Code rules. Section 56b gives an executed hold the effect of a legal ban on disposal. [1]
- If a reachable custodial exchange owes a customer an attachable claim, customs could serve the order on the exchange under the bill’s corresponding attachment rules. The exchange could then restrict withdrawals it controls. [1] [2] [3]
- For a property right with no third-party debtor, Fiscal Code section 321 allows attachment by serving the holder with a prohibition on disposal. Applied by analogy under the bill, service would impose a legal restraint in an eligible self-custody case without itself changing who can sign a Bitcoin transaction. [1] [4] [3]
Method
The branches apply the attachment and disposal rules in §§56a–56b and the corresponding Fiscal Code service rules to two custody arrangements.
Scope
Illustrative cases under the Bundestag-approved bill. The diagram covers the effect of serving the attachment order.
CryptoSlateGermany's Blockchain Bundesverband highlighted this enforcement challenge in a submission on an earlier version of the legislation. The industry association explained that authorities must distinguish between cryptocurrencies held by custodians and assets controlled directly by individuals.
It also warned that identifying a blockchain wallet does not necessarily establish who controls its assets, particularly where multiple parties share transaction-signing authority.
These complications could make enforcing restrictions on self-custody wallets harder than freezing balances held by regulated exchanges.
The legislation also distinguishes temporary asset freezes from permanent confiscation, which would require a separate finance court decision establishing that the property originated unlawfully.
Should the bill complete Germany's legislative process, its effectiveness against self-custodied crypto holdings will depend on authorities' ability to identify wallet controllers and enforce legal restrictions without direct control of their private keys.
Mentioned in this article
Editorial credits
Oluwapelumi values Bitcoin's potential. He imparts insights on a range of topics like DeFi, hacks, mining and culture, underlining transformative power.